EssaySnark

  • about
  • contact
  • help
  • sign up
  • login
CLICK FOR MORE!
  • Essay Questions
    • Harvard
    • Stanford
    • Wharton
    • Chicago Booth
    • Kellogg
    • MIT Sloan
    • Tuck
    • NYU Stern
    • Columbia
    • Yale SOM
    • Berkeley Haas
    • UVA Darden
    • Duke Fuqua
    • Michigan Ross
    • UCLA Anderson
    • Cornell
  • Strategy Guides
    • MBA Interviewing Guide
    • Getting Off the Waitlist
    • Applying in Round 3 mini-guide
    • Applying to European Business Schools
    • School-Specific MBA Application Guides
      • Columbia 2020 MBA Strategy Guide
      • Harvard 2020 MBA Strategy Guide
      • Kellogg 2020 MBA Strategy Guide
      • MIT Sloan 2020 MBA Strategy Guide
      • Chicago Booth 2020 MBA Strategy Guide
      • *MORE SCHOOL-SPECIFIC GUIDES HERE*
  • MBA Consulting
    • Free essay reviews
    • What stage are you in?
    • Military MBA
    • BIPOC Program
    • Testimonials & Reviews
    • Guest Posts
  • My SnarkCenter
    • My Strategy Guides
    • My Favorite Posts
    • Discounts & Offers

($) The downsides of alumni interviewing

October 4, 2019 by EssaySnark Leave a Comment

This post is kind of in the category of “informative but potentially useless” (hmm, how many of our posts are in that category??? we, of course, write them to be useful, but do you actually use them? The ‘Snark ponders).

Knowing that there are downsides to going through an alumni interview for your MBA application, as compared to an interview conducted by a student, or best yet, by an MBA admissions representative, could potentially only serve to stress you out. After all, it’s not like you have any control over the way your target MBA program conducts its interviews.

If we sit here today and tell you that it’s not ideal to have an alum interviewing you, and you have exactly that sort of interviewing coming up next week, what are you supposed to do with that information? It’s not like you can call the admissions office up and say “Hey this isn’t gonna work, can you assign someone better to interview me?”

Over the years we’ve been doing this, a handful of schools have moved away from alumni interviews, and the reason for that is very basic:

Alumni tend to be kind of lame at the interviewing function.

Wharton, for example, started experimenting with the interview process in 2011. For years and years, interviews were all done the same there: You got your interview invite, and you got hooked up with a Wharton alum in your city, who conducted the interview with you and then reported his or her findings back to admissions. Many schools still do things this way. It’s efficient in terms of time and resources, particularly with such big schools like Columbia and Kellogg that interview a lot of candidates.

The downsides to this though are quality control – the admissions office often is unable to do much training, nor do they have much oversight over their alums. It creates a nonstandard experience for the candidates, and the post-interview reports submitted back into admissions have a lot of variability.

Wharton and Columbia and Booth have tried to counter that by integrating standard questions into their interviews, and Wharton even made an attempt to change those standard questions regularly, like every round. But that doesn’t work, for obvious reasons: Immediately after they interview, lots of candidates run straight to their computers to post about their experiences on those applicant forums you spend too much time on. They spill the beans pretty much immediately. Oftentimes, the alumni don’t get with the program and ask the current version of questions anyway.

In 2011, Wharton made a big step of pulling in their interviews. They took the task off the shoulders of their alumni and instead moved to a more closely-managed process where only adcom members and — mostly — current students do them. UCLA has done the same, where they don’t have alumni doing the interviews anymore. For its part-time Evening & Weekends program, Berkeley Haas has even replaced in-person interviews completely with video questions (that seems a little drastic and they are now sacrificing the personal experience for candidates, which would be the subject of a separate post). Other schools encourage candidates to come to campus to interview, Yale and Darden and Tuck among them. That means that specially-trained second-year students are doing the interview, and the admissions office can centrally manage the process. Plus, what a great opportunity for students to build important skills in interviewing.

Pro Tip: A good interviewer does not happen by accident. A good interviewer has trained and practiced to get good at it.

And oh hey! That’s true for you the interviewee too! The best advice we can offer to anyone lucky enough to be interviewing for their schools is to PRACTICE. Our MBA Interviewing Guide offers plenty more suggestions than that, but if you take away nothing from today’s post except you must practice for your interview then we will be satisfied that we have accomplished our objective today.

We’ve long felt that alumni are not the best interviewers unless the process is managed very carefully, as it’s done at London Business School, for example. We were happy to see Wharton relieve their alum from these interviewing duties way back when. (Sometimes Lauder alumni still perform interviews for that program but it’s more unusual.) We keep hoping that other schools will find a way to do this as well, but we appreciate the challenges, when a school is interviewing vast numbers of applicants all over the world, like Kellogg is.

So what do you do if you get an alumni interviewing you? Well, we do discuss this in that MBA Interviewing Guide but just briefly, so you don’t feel cheated to have read a 600-word post and not gotten anything out of it: You need to practice and you need to be flexible An alum might go in who-knows-how-many different directions. These interviews tend to be somewhat less predictable than what you would face in a by-student interview at the school. (A by-adcom interview is sort of a different animal, and we definitely suggest that you enlist our custom interview questions service to prepare for that.)

Some alumnus/a are actually the easiest interviews in the world. They’re totally laid back and they mostly are willing to rubber-stamp you. How valuable that will be for the admissions committee is a separate conversation (hint: not much, probably) but the interview experience itself may be chill.

Some alumnus/a have a chip on their shoulder, and seem to think their job is to serve as gatekeeper, and test you. Those can be grueling and emotionally a lot of no-fun.

In either case: You need to be prepared.

If the laid-back interviewer seems not to be asking you questions that let you share how awesome you are professionally, then see if you can insert such examples of awesome in somewhere anyway. They often may ask “Anything else you want to share?” and that’s your opportunity.

The best way to prepare for a hard-nosed interviewer is to be ultra prepared.

So the answer to the question of how to deal with a not-so-great interviewer is the same in both cases. No matter which extreme end of the spectrum you get.

And of course, if you end up with a great interviewer, who knows how to interview, who’s able to put you at ease and ask good questions that let you share yourself authentically…. well, obviously you need to be prepared, in order to maximize that opportunity, too!

So, apparently there is usefulness here. If you’re interviewing, PLEASE BE PREPARED! Just because you’re going to be asked questions about you, your career, why MBA, and just because you answered those questions a month ago when submitting your essays, doe NOT mean you’re ready to answer those questions verbally when you’re put on the spot and feeling tongue-tied and nervous. Please practice, BSer! It’s super important for success in this process.

And yes indeedy, this will help you:

EssaySnark's MBA Interview Prep Guide

 
 

Filed Under: interviewing

« Previous: We don’t publish sample essays for your own benefit, and now we have science to back that policy up
Next: Learning to be a better writer (like, hey, the way EssaySnark coaches!) can help you at Amazon »

So who the heck is EssaySnark, anyway?!

We're the snarky experts in MBA admissions!

Sometimes amused and often appalled by what candidates write in their MBA applications to top bschools, EssaySnark created this little blahg to share common mistakes. Learn from them and avoid making admissions directors laugh (or want to hurl) when they read your essays. If you are hoping to have your essay reviewed anonymously on the blahg for free, submit it for consideration.

Want EssaySnark's personal assistance with your MBA applications? Start with our menu of consulting services and please read the Help FAQ to learn how we operate. Still have questions after doing all that? Email Team EssaySnark at gethelpnow at essaysnark dot com.

Good luck on your apps, Brave Supplicant!

Tell us what you think. Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for the 'Snark via email

Enter your address to get weekday blahg posts by email.

UPCOMING MBA APP DEADLINES

  • INSEAD Round 4
    in 1 month, 0 weeks, 0 days, 7 hours
  • INSEAD Jan '22 intake Rd 1
    in 1 month, 1 week, 3 days, 7 hours
  • INSEAD Jan '22 Intake Rd 2
    in 2 months, 4 weeks, 0 days, 7 hours
  • (expected) HBS Class of 2024 app requirements released
    in 3 months, 1 week, 4 days, 8 hours
  • (expected) Columbia J-Term/ED app to open
    in 4 months, 1 week, 2 days, 8 hours
   
From a BSer January 2020:
"love the guide books!"


CLASS OF 2023 MBA APPLICATION STRATEGY GUIDES

     
    The 2020 Berkeley-Haas MBA Application Guide - updated for the Class of 2023 application!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Berkeley Haas - refreshed and updated, with brainstorming exercises and structured maps to help you focus your stories!
   
    The 2020-2021 NYU Stern MBA Application Guide that covers the main essay, the EQ Endorsement and Pick Six!
SnarkStrategies Guide for NYU - discusses your requirements for the Class of 2023 essays!
   
    The 2020-2021 Columbia MBA Application Guide
SnarkStrategies Guide for Columbia Business School for 2020-2021 applications
   
    The 2020 Harvard MBA Application Guide - completely overhauled and updated for the coronavirus era!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Harvard Business School!
   
    The 2020-2021 Duke Essay Guide - covers the 25 Random Things essay and all the rest too!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Duke Fuqua - up to date for the current season!
   
    The 2020-2021 MIT Essay Guide covers the org chart, the contacts for two references, and additional tips for the cover letter and 'introduce yourself' video -- and everything else you need to know!
SnarkStrategies Guide for MIT Sloan MBA - totally revised for the Class of 2023!
   
    The 2020-2021 Tuck Essay Guide has been refreshed with latest insights and advice for your essays about "investing generously" and "why Tuck"!
SnarkStrategies Guide for the Dartmouth Tuck MBA - completely overhauled for 2020, to help you demonstrate how you are nice, aware, etc stuff!
   
    The Yale SOM MBA Application Guide for Class of 2023 candidates!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Yale SOM - updated for 2020-2021
   
    The 2020-2021 Chicago Booth MBA Application Guide - ready to go to support your Class of 2023 essay strategy!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Chicago Booth for this year's MBA app!
   
    The 2020 Wharton MBA Application Guide - even more advice on how to get to a win with those essays!
SnarkStrategies Guide for The Wharton School - with new tips for 2020!
   
    The 2020 Kellogg Essay Guide - with a full methodology to identify your 'lasting impact' and your 'values' -- plus tips on 2020 world events and applicability to your essays!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Kellogg MBA - updated and revised for the new realities of 2020!    
      The 2020 Stanford MBA Application Guide - for "what matters most" in your MBA application!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Stanford GSB for the Class of 2023
   
    The 2020-2021 UCLA Anderson MBA Application Guide - updated for Class of 2023 on "impact"!
SnarkStrategies Guide for 
UCLA
   
   

Brave Supplicants' latest reviews on The 'Snark


Apr 10, 2020
by George on EssaySnark
Great Starting Point

I thought getting over the GRE/GMAT hurdle was fairly straightforward--disciplined study then test execution... Read more

Apr 10, 2020
by George on Single Shot Express MBA Essay Review
Worth Every Penny

I used the Single Shot Express to decimate essay #1 at my first-choice school. Paired with the school... Read more

Feb 9, 2020
by KA on Waitlist Assist
Committed

You continue to blow me away with your commitment to us BSers! Thanks again for everything. It's been... Read more






Not sure where to begin with EssaySnark?
Our Snark Selector
will tell you!



What were we snarking about at this time in past years?

  • 2020: ($) What about Round 3?
  • 2018: Good luck today if you're hoping for Harvard!
  • 2017: ($) You got the interview!! So what are you going to wear???
  • 2017: ($) How will Round 2 go for international MBA applicants to U.S. bschools? [UPDATED]
  • 2016: ($) The other school that may still be viable for an app this season.
  • 2016: ($) Applying to bschool right now is foolish. Unless you're thinking of ...
  • 2015: A reminder of what to expect with Harvard interview invites tomorrow
  • 2015: Does it matter who the dean is?
  • 2014: Entrepreneurship at Columbia: One student's report
My Tweets

See the Top U.S. Business Schools on a Map!


EssaySnark is currently available! We're accepting new clients! Standard turnarounds apply. If you're in a hurry, Speedy Review is available!

EssaySnark® is a registered trademark. All content copyright © 2010–2021 Snarkolicious Press · Privacy Policy

Where should you start with EssaySnark?

Which EssaySnark service is right for you? Answer a few questions to find out!

This field must be set to Everyone - then in the Settings -> HTML -> After Fields screen there's JavaScript to hide it.
Sending