This is not a rhetorical question. Should you consider your interactions with the adcom when you evaluate whether a school is the right fit for you? Exhibit A – received from a BSer who made it into multiple schools in Round 1: I wanted to touch base and let you know how things ended up…
While much of the blahg is available completely for free, the content here is reserved for members with full blahg access only ($9.95/month for six months, cancel anytime). Please login to view this content or purchase a membership.
levieillard says
At this point in the game, I would try to break through admissions to reach the rest of the school to make a decision. Network directly with professors, students, and alumni, and try to visit. Ask for a conversation, be excited and friendly, but politely raise the issue, “I’m concerned about my experience with the admissions department.. what’s your perspective on the difference between them and the rest of the school?”
To the degree the choice is personal, there is no wrong answer. But if there are material differences between the schools in areas that matter (e.g. location, recruiting, academics, culture, scholarships, etc.), then it turns into a problem.
I would also consider writing a letter to share your experience with the appropriate dean if you decline, using a carefully chosen tone.
Bschool2013 says
The Veterans network is a big one. If its weak during the admissions process, you can bet it’ll be weak during your time at school too.