EssaySnark

  • about
  • contact
  • help
  • sign up
  • login
CLICK FOR MORE!
  • Essay Questions
    • Harvard
    • Stanford
    • Wharton
    • Chicago Booth
    • Kellogg
    • MIT Sloan
    • Tuck
    • NYU Stern
    • Columbia
    • Yale SOM
    • Berkeley Haas
    • UVA Darden
    • Duke Fuqua
    • Michigan Ross
    • UCLA Anderson
    • Cornell
  • Strategy Guides
    • MBA Reapplicant Guide
    • Pitching Entrepreneurship as Your Post-MBA Career
    • Applying to European Business Schools
    • School-Specific MBA Application Guides
      • Harvard 2022 MBA Strategy Guide
      • Stanford 2022 MBA Strategy Guide
      • Wharton 2022 MBA Strategy Guide
      • Kellogg 2022 MBA Strategy Guide
      • Chicago Booth 2022 MBA Strategy Guide
      • Columbia 2022 MBA Strategy Guide
      • *MORE SCHOOL-SPECIFIC GUIDES HERE*
  • MBA Consulting
    • Free essay reviews
    • What stage are you in?
    • Military MBA
    • Testimonials & Reviews
  • My SnarkCenter
    • My Strategy Guides
    • My Favorite Posts

Reliance on bschool rankings is a trap

October 5, 2011 by EssaySnark - Discusses Chicago Booth, Dartmouth Tuck 2 Comments

A question was left on an unrelated post recently asking about EssaySnark’s offhand comment that we would choose Tuck or INSEAD over Booth. The Brave Supplicant said: “As far as I know Booth has a better reputation compared to Tuck. Isn’t it?”

Let’s get something straight: Ranking alone is not how anyone should be choosing a bschool.

OK. We got that out of the way. (We may say it a couple more times before we’re done.)

Let’s explore.

If by “reputation” you actually mean “ranking” then it’s debatable. Yes, Booth has sat at #1 on the BusinessWeek charts for, what, six years now? However, in that same time, Tuck has hit near the top of just as many other major rankings systems, including some global ones. The 2010 Economist ranking has Booth at #1 and Tuck at #2. Seems pretty neck-and-neck to us.

But we’re not so star-struck as to put such a premium on what some fancy-pants publication claims is “the best” – this is education we’re talking about, and that’s actually a pretty personal thing, wouldn’t you agree? This is not a one-size-fits-all proposition, and that’s where the overreliance on rankings systems can lead you astray.

As we said, there are a LOT of factors that go into (or SHOULD go into) choosing a school. The experience of going to Tuck, versus Booth, is vastly different, in so many ways. What are pluses for someone about a certain school are negatives for others. Different schools attract different types of people. Some companies recruit only at certain schools. Even the classroom experience (and the out-of-classroom experience for sure) is often school-specific. These differences need to be experienced firsthand in order to know which school is right for you.

If by “reputation” you mean REPUTATION, then Tuck has more clout in certain circles than Booth does. We’ve heard that Tuck has serious connections in private equity, for example. And the Tuck has street cred. Most conisseurs of the MBA (as EssaySnark likes to think we are) would agree that Tuck is at least as good on both reputation AND ranking as Booth.

But here’s the kicker: The fact that the darn rankings change regularly is enough to show that they should not be relied on exclusively. About every ten years, the rankings change fairly radically. Did you know that Wharton was the #1 prima donna darling among the bschool brat pack for most of the ’90s? And by saying today that Chicago is #1, what are you saying about the perennial favorite (based on app volume), Harvard? Or what about Stanford? Are you really telling us, BusinessWeek, that Booth is better than Stanford??

Hmm.

The bottom line with rankings is that they must change every year (or every two years) in order for the publication that publishes them to stay relevant. Nobody’s gonna keep buying the annual US News & World Report Top MBA Programs Special Edition Whoop-Di-Whoop (that’ll set you back a cool $10+) if the darn schools show up in the same order every year. Nobody’s gonna keep believing that BusinessWeek is some authority on bschools if they don’t do this song and dance around a new list every other year. Do you really think a slow-moving behemoth of a bschool is able to change enough in a year or two to affect its order on a rankings scale? This stuff is so subjective (and we’re not even going into the part about how the rankings can be manipulated by the schools themselves!).

Here is the moral of this story: If you pick your bschool based solely on ranking, then you are GUARANTEED to be dissatisfied in a year or two. Because that’s when a new set of rankings will come out, and it’s HIGHLY LIKELY that your Chosen One will no longer be first! Maybe not the first time, maybe not the next time, but soon.

Let’s revisit our takeaway message that we lobbed out there at the very beginning, as this is most important: Your choice of a bschool is VERY personal. Many many factors should be taken into account besides just what some magazine says is “the best.” You need to (OMG no say it isn’t true) go visit the school to understand what the school is about.

So to reiterate our answer to the Brave Supplicant who wondered, isn’t Booth better than Tuck?

Tuck is a better program IN OUR OPINION, and we would choose it over Booth. We might even recommend that others should do so, when we have a little info on them/their goals. But that does not mean that EVERYONE would or should choose Tuck, and it definitely does not mean that Booth is a lesser-than school.

Filed Under: selecting schools Tagged With: private equity, rankings Bschools: Chicago Booth, Dartmouth Tuck

« Previous: essay critique: Columbia essay 2 “life experience”
Next: Tips on cutting it down to size (overlimit essays) »

So who the heck is EssaySnark, anyway?!

We're the snarky experts in MBA admissions!

Sometimes amused and often appalled by what candidates write in their MBA applications to top bschools, EssaySnark created this little blahg to share common mistakes. Learn from them and avoid making admissions directors laugh (or want to hurl) when they read your essays. If you are hoping to have your essay reviewed anonymously on the blahg for free, submit it for consideration.

Want EssaySnark's personal assistance with your MBA applications? Start with our menu of consulting services and please read the Help FAQ to learn how we operate. Still have questions after doing all that? Email Team EssaySnark at gethelpnow at essaysnark dot com.

Good luck on your apps, Brave Supplicant!

Here's what others have said about this:

  1. Dan V says

    October 5, 2011 at 3:35 pm

    Great points. Never really though about it that way because I've only been MBA ranking obsessed for 1 year.

    your post was so good that i changed my mind and I am now applying to Tuck instead of Booth….

    just kidding, but I'm someone had that reaction.

    Reply
  2. essaysnark says

    October 5, 2011 at 3:49 pm

    LOL Dan V – didn't realize but yes, probably someone will! Obviously EssaySnark is no authority in what's the right school for anyone. We'd tried to get this post up a few weeks back but other stuff (like essay critiques!) kept getting in the way – the timing of this rant was not by design. At this late date we're not expecting anyone to change up their strategy.

    Hopefully you'll *only* be rankings-obsessed for a year – not longer – because you'll GET IN this year!! Good luck with upcoming apps!

    Reply

Tell us what you think. Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for the 'Snark via email

Enter your address to get weekday blahg posts by email.

UPCOMING MBA APP DEADLINES

  • INSEAD Jan '24 intake Rd 1
    in 1 month, 1 week, 2 days
  • INSEAD Round 4
    in 1 month, 1 week, 2 days
  • INSEAD Jan '24 Intake Rd 2
    in 2 months, 2 weeks, 6 days
  • INSEAD Jan '24 Intake Rd 3
    in 4 months, 4 weeks, 1 day
  • INSEAD Jan '24 Intake Rd 4
    in 6 months, 1 week, 3 days
   
   

CLASS OF 2025 MBA APPLICATION STRATEGY GUIDES

From a former BSer:
"love the guide books!"




    The 2022 Stanford MBA Application Guide - for "what matters most" in your MBA application!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Stanford GSB for the Class of 2025
   
    The 2022 Harvard MBA Application Guide - updated for the Class of 2025!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Harvard Business School!
   
  The 2022 Wharton MBA Application Guide - even more advice on how to get to a win with those essays!
SnarkStrategies Guide for The Wharton School - with clear guidance for the 2022 essays!
   
  The 2022-2023 Columbia MBA Application Guide
SnarkStrategies Guide for Columbia Business School for 2022-2023 applications
   
    The 2022 MIT Essay Guide covers the org chart, the cover letter and 'introduce yourself' video, plus the new optional short-answer question on "the world you come from" -- and everything else you need to know!
SnarkStrategies Guide for MIT Sloan MBA - totally revised for the Class of 2025!
   
    The 2022 Kellogg Essay Guide - with a full methodology to identify your 'lasting impact' and your 'values'
SnarkStrategies Guide for Kellogg MBA - revised for 2022!
   
    The 2022 UVA Darden MBA Application Guide gives insights on the essays, Early Action, the possibility of a test waiver, and everything else going on here!
SnarkStrategies Guide for the Darden MBA - updated for the Class of 2025 requirements!
   
   
The Yale SOM MBA Application Guide for Class of 2025 candidates!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Yale SOM - updated for 2022
   
    The 2022 Berkeley-Haas MBA Application Guide - updated for the Class of 2025 application!
SnarkStrategies Guide for Berkeley Haas - refreshed and updated, with brainstorming exercises and structured maps to help you focus your stories!
   
    The 2022-2023 NYU Stern MBA Application Guide that covers the essays, the EQ Endorsement and test strategies!
SnarkStrategies Guide for NYU - discusses your requirements for the Class of 2025 essays!
       
   
   
Get started now - without doing any work! The Comprehensive Profile Review will help you start your strategy for your MBA applications.


EssaySnark® is a registered trademark. All content copyright © 2010–2023 Snarkolicious Press · Privacy Policy